Skip to content

Newcastle United vs Everton Prediction & Betting Tips – Premier League

Published Oct 31, 2026
Updated Oct 30, 2026
12 mins read
newcastle-united
premier-league
Premier League
everton
Newcastle United
Mon, 02 Nov, 20:00
Everton
Home
2.25
Draw
3.41
Away
2.83
Bet now

Newcastle vs Everton Goals and Odds Analysis

Newcastle United and Everton both average 1.2 goals scored per game across all competitions, but defensive metrics reveal a clear divergence ahead of Monday, 2 Nov 2026 at 20:00 UTC. Newcastle United concede an average of 1.8 goals per match, compared to Everton’s 1.4 goals conceded per game. This variance in defensive efficiency directly impacts match probability distributions and market valuations for this Premier League fixture.

Newcastle United Defensive Struggles and Form

Date Competition Opponent Score Result
2026-10-29 League Cup Everton 1-3 Loss
2026-10-25 Premier League Crystal Palace 2-0 Win
2026-10-17 Premier League Aston Villa 0-1 Loss
2026-10-12 Premier League Coventry 1-4 Loss
2026-09-19 Premier League Hull City 2-1 Win
Average Goals Scored:1.2 goals/game
Average Goals Conceded:1.8 conceded/game
Current Form:LWLLW

Across their last five matches in all competitions, Newcastle United have recorded two wins and three losses, holding a form of LWLLW. Their most recent outing resulted in a 1-3 home defeat against Everton in the League Cup on 2026-10-29. Conceding 1.8 goals per game highlights ongoing defensive vulnerabilities that undermine their home performance metrics.

Everton Defensive Metrics and Recent Results

Date Competition Opponent Score Result
2026-10-29 League Cup Newcastle 3-1 Win
2026-10-24 Premier League Arsenal 0-2 Loss
2026-10-17 Premier League Chelsea 0-2 Loss
2026-10-11 Premier League Hull City 2-2 Draw
2026-09-19 Premier League Ipswich 1-0 Win
Average Goals Scored:1.2 goals/game
Average Goals Conceded:1.4 conceded/game
Current Form:WLLDW

Everton enter this fixture with recent overall form showing two wins, one draw, and two defeats (WLLDW). Their recent 3-1 away victory over Newcastle United on 2026-10-29 demonstrated an ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities away from home. Yielding 1.4 goals per match gives Everton a tighter defensive baseline relative to their hosts.

Head-to-Head Record Favors Everton

In six recorded head-to-head encounters, Everton lead with three victories, while Newcastle United have secured one win alongside two draws. Everton won the most recent meeting 3-1 in League Cup action on 2026-10-29, following a 3-2 league victory on 2026-02-28. Newcastle United’s sole recent head-to-head win was a 4-1 away result on 2025-11-29.

Date Competition Match Score Winner
2026-02-28 Premier League Newcastle vs Everton 2-3 Everton
2025-11-29 Premier League Everton vs Newcastle 1-4 Newcastle
2025-05-25 Premier League Newcastle vs Everton 0-1 Everton
2024-10-05 Premier League Everton vs Newcastle 0-0 Draw
2024-04-02 Premier League Newcastle vs Everton 1-1 Draw
2023-12-07 Premier League Everton vs Newcastle 3-0 Everton
Newcastle United Wins:1
Draws:2
Everton Wins:3

Predicted Lineups and Absence Report

Newcastle United – Predicted XI

4-3-3
Position Player
Goalkeeper N. Pope
Defender T. Livramento
Defender S. Botman
Defender M. Thiaw
Defender L. Hall
Midfielder Joelinton
Midfielder J. Willock
Midfielder L. Miley
Attacker A. Elanga
Attacker Y. Wissa
Midfielder J. Murphy

Everton – Predicted XI

4-3-3
Position Player
Goalkeeper J. Pickford
Midfielder A. Maitland-Niles
Defender J. O'Brien
Defender M. Keane
Defender V. Mykolenko
Midfielder C. Nørgaard
Midfielder J. Garner
Midfielder K. Dewsbury-Hall
Attacker T. Dibling
Attacker T. Barry
Midfielder Tyrique George

Team News

Newcastle United absences: No key absences.

Everton absences: No key absences.

Expected Value Assessment and Market Odds

Bookmaker odds place Newcastle United as home favorites at 2.25, reflecting an implied probability of 44.4%. However, our statistical model calculates Newcastle United’s true win probability at only 35%, yielding a negative expected value of -21.3%. Draw odds sit at 3.41 against an estimated 25% model probability (-14.7% expected value). Conversely, Everton are priced at 2.83 (implied probability of 35.3%), whereas our model assesses their win probability at 40%. This divergence generates a +13.2% expected value edge on the away win, establishing Everton as the primary value pick.

Market Selection Odds Value Rating
Match Result Newcastle United 2.25 No value
Draw Draw 3.41 No value
Match Result Everton 2.83 ★★ Value

Model Projection and Final Verdict

Statistical indicators favor Everton based on lower goal concession rates and recent head-to-head outcomes. Our model projects a 40% probability for an away win compared to 35% for the home team. The recommended selection is an Away Win for Everton.

Predicted Score Newcastle United 1-2 Everton
Most Likely Result Away Win
Recommended Bet Away Win @ 2.83 (EV +13%)

How This Prediction Was Made

This prediction was prepared by Oliver Grant. The pick combines Oliver’s experience following European football with data gathered for this specific match. Data used: each team’s last five results, head-to-head history, injury and suspension news, pre-match odds, our own outcome probabilities.

Responsible Gambling

18+. This prediction is an opinion based on data, not a guarantee. Betting involves risk – only stake what you can afford to lose and gamble responsibly.

Oliver Grant
Oliver Grant
football Football Expert
314 art.
Football tactical analyst from London, UK. Oliver has over a 8 years of experience covering European Leagues and UEFA competitions. Known for his data-driven insights and calm, analytical style.

Who will win? Vote Now!

Pick the result, see your payout & claim a free gift 🎁

Premier League
Newcastle United
vs
Everton
$

Select an outcome to vote